If a used car goes wrong soon after you buy it, what you can do about it depends mostly on who sold it to you. Buying from a dealer gives you strong rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Buying privately gives you far fewer. Auctions sit somewhere else again. This guide explains each one in plain English.
The short version
From a dealer, the car must be of satisfactory quality, fit for purpose and as described. You have 30 days to reject a faulty car, then a right to a repair or replacement, then a final right to reject (with a deduction for use). From a private seller, the car must be as described and the seller must have the right to sell it. Buy privately in good faith a car that turns out to have hire purchase owing, and the law often protects you.
Not legal advice
This is a general guide to the law, written in plain English. Every case is different. For advice on your own situation, contact Citizens Advice or a solicitor.
Buying from a dealer: the Consumer Rights Act 2015
When you buy from a trader, the Consumer Rights Act treats every sale as including these terms:
- Satisfactory quality. The car must meet the standard a reasonable person would think satisfactory, taking account of the description, the price and all other relevant circumstances. Durability is one of the things that counts.
- Fit for a particular purpose. If you told the dealer before buying what you needed the car for, for example towing a caravan, it must be reasonably fit for that purpose.
- As described. The car must match the description, including what the advert and the dealer told you.
- The right to sell. The trader must have the right to sell the car to you.
There's an important limit. The satisfactory quality term doesn't cover a fault the dealer specifically pointed out before you bought, or one that your own inspection ought to have revealed if you examined the car first. Read the advert and any paperwork about known faults carefully.
What you can do if a dealer's car is faulty
The Act gives you three tiers of remedy, in this order:
- The short-term right to reject (30 days). If the car is faulty, you can reject it and ask for a full refund within 30 days. The 30 days start the day after you take ownership and delivery of the car.
- Repair or replacement. After 30 days, or if you choose to, you can ask the dealer to repair or replace the car. The dealer must do it within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience to you, and must pay the costs, including parts and labour. The dealer can refuse one option if it's impossible or disproportionate compared to the other.
- Price reduction or the final right to reject. If one repair or replacement fails to fix the problem, or the dealer doesn't do it in a reasonable time, you can ask for money off the price or reject the car for a refund. You can choose one of these, not both.
Cars are treated differently on refunds. For most goods, the Act says no deduction for use can be made from a final-right-to-reject refund in the first 6 months. Motor vehicles are a named exception, so if you use the final right to reject, the dealer can reduce your refund to take account of the use you've had from the car. There's no deduction under the 30-day short-term right to reject.
The 6-month rule
If a fault shows up within 6 months of delivery, the law assumes it was there when you bought the car, unless the dealer can prove it wasn't, or the assumption doesn't fit the type of fault. After 6 months, it's usually up to you to show the fault was there at the time of sale, for example with a report from an independent garage.
Buying from a private seller
A private sale is covered by the Sale of Goods Act 1979, not the Consumer Rights Act. The satisfactory quality term in that Act only applies where the seller sells in the course of a business, so a private seller doesn't promise the car is of satisfactory quality. What they must do is:
- Describe it accurately. Goods sold by description must correspond with the description. That covers what's said in the advert, messages and conversations, for example about mileage, service history, previous damage or how many owners it's had.
- Have the right to sell it. The seller must actually be entitled to sell the car.
So with a private car, it's up to you to spot problems before you pay. If it turns out not to be as described, Citizens Advice has a template letter for misdescribed goods bought from a private seller. Save the advert and messages so you can show what you were told. Citizens Advice also suggests viewing at the seller's home, so you know where to find them if something goes wrong.
Watch for traders pretending to be private sellers to avoid their legal duties. If someone has several cars for sale, or the name on the V5C doesn't match, be cautious. Our guides to buying a car privately and used car scams cover the warning signs.
Buying at auction
Citizens Advice calls auctions probably the riskiest way to buy a used car. Under the Consumer Rights Act, you're generally not treated as a consumer when you buy second-hand goods at a public auction that individuals can attend in person, so most of the dealer rights above don't apply. Read the auction house's terms and conditions carefully before you bid.
If the car still has finance owing
A car on hire purchase or conditional sale belongs to the finance company until the last payment is made. If the borrower sells it anyway, Part III of the Hire Purchase Act 1964 can protect you. According to Citizens Advice, you often have the right to keep the car (called "good title") if:
- you didn't know it was under a finance agreement,
- you bought it honestly, in good faith,
- you're a private individual, not someone in the business of buying cars to sell or of providing finance, and
- you're the first private buyer from the person who had the finance (if you're not, you may still have good title through the previous owner).
Citizens Advice says the finance company has to prove you don't have good title, not the other way round. If they contact you, write back explaining you bought in good faith, with the seller's details, the date, the price, the advert and your receipt. See Citizens Advice: the car you bought is still on hire purchase.
The protection only helps if you genuinely didn't know, so a vehicle history check before you buy is still the best defence. Selling a car with finance on it yourself? Read selling a car with outstanding finance.
Where to get help
- Talk to the seller first. Put your complaint in writing, say what's wrong and what you want (a refund, repair or replacement), and keep copies.
- Citizens Advice consumer service. Advisers can explain the law and pass complaints on to Trading Standards. See getting more help with a consumer issue.
- Trade associations and The Motor Ombudsman. Citizens Advice suggests checking whether a dealer belongs to a trade association, as you can act through it if something goes wrong. The Motor Ombudsman runs codes of practice for the motor industry, including a Vehicle Sales Code for car retailers, and offers dispute resolution.
- Finance through the dealer. If the dealer arranged your finance, Citizens Advice says you may be able to take action against the finance company as well as the dealer.
- Court as a last resort. In England and Wales you can make a court claim for money online. GOV.UK points out that mediation could be quicker and cheaper. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own processes.
Frequently asked questions
Check before you buy
The best protection is spotting problems first. Use our used car checklist, read what to check before buying a used car, then browse cars for sale.