"Automatic" in a car advert can mean four very different gearboxes. Some are smooth and tough, and some are known for expensive problems. Two cars with the same badge and the same "automatic" label can have completely different gearboxes depending on the engine and year. This guide explains the four types, which ones need extra care on a used car, and how to find out what a car actually has before you go and see it.
The short version
A conventional (torque-converter) automatic is usually the safest choice on an older, cheaper car. CVTs and dual-clutch boxes can be fine but need checking carefully. Automated manuals ("semi-automatics") are often jerky to drive and need the most caution. Find out the exact gearbox from the model, engine and year, not from the word "automatic" in the advert.
The four types at a glance
| Type | How it works | How it drives | Used-buyer view |
|---|---|---|---|
| Torque-converter automatic | A fluid coupling and a set of fixed gears that change themselves | Smooth, can feel less efficient on older 4-speed boxes | Usually the most forgiving on an older car |
| CVT | Pulleys and a belt or chain give endless ratios instead of fixed gears | Very smooth; engine can drone when you accelerate hard | Fine when looked after; check fluid changes |
| Dual-clutch (DSG, DCT, PowerShift) | Two clutches pre-select the next gear | Quick changes, can be hesitant at low speed | Some versions have well-documented faults |
| Automated manual (AMT) | A normal manual gearbox and single clutch, worked by motors | Pauses and lurches between gears | Needs the most caution |
1. Torque-converter automatics
This is the traditional automatic, used for decades in everything from small hatchbacks to big saloons. Instead of a clutch, a fluid coupling called a torque converter connects the engine to a set of fixed gears that change on their own. Older ones often have only four gears, so they can use a bit more fuel than a manual, but they're usually tough and smooth.
Examples on popular used cars include the 2008 to 2012 Ford Fiesta 1.4 automatic (a conventional four-speed), the Nissan Note 1.6 automatic of 2006 to 2013 (also a four-speed), the four-speed automatic in the Hyundai i10, and Peugeot and Citroën's later EAT6 and EAT8 gearboxes.
2. CVT (continuously variable transmission)
A CVT has no fixed gears. Two pulleys connected by a steel belt or chain change size smoothly, so the engine can stay at its most efficient speed. It feels seamless, though the engine note can rise and stay high when you accelerate hard. Nissan calls its CVT "Xtronic" (used on the petrol Juke automatic, for example), and Toyota calls its non-hybrid CVT "Multidrive S".
CVTs depend on the right fluid, changed on time. The first-generation Honda Jazz CVT (2002 to 2008) is known for reports of judder, often linked to the fluid. A CVT that's failing can be very expensive to repair or replace, so ask for proof of fluid changes and walk away from one that slips, shudders or whines.
Toyota hybrids are different. Their "e-CVT" doesn't use a belt at all: a set of gears blends power from the petrol engine and electric motors. It drives like a CVT but works in a completely different way, so don't judge it by the problems of belt-type CVTs.
3. Dual-clutch gearboxes
A dual-clutch gearbox is like two manual gearboxes in one: while you're in one gear, the next is already selected, so changes are very fast. Volkswagen Group cars (VW, Audi, SEAT, Skoda) call it DSG, and Ford calls its version PowerShift. Some dual-clutch gearboxes are reliable, but two families are well known for problems:
- Ford PowerShift (dry clutch) in the Fiesta, Focus, B-Max and EcoSport of the 2010s. Problems with shuddering and clutches were serious enough to lead to a class action in the United States, settled in 2017.
- VW Group 7-speed dry-clutch DSG (known as DQ200), fitted to many smaller VW, Audi, SEAT and Skoda models. VW has run campaigns in several countries for its mechatronic control unit, covering gearboxes built from 2008 to late 2014.
On any used dual-clutch car, ask whether recall or software work has been done, and check for outstanding recalls using the DVSA vehicle recall checker. On the test drive, watch for juddering when pulling away, hesitation, or a warning light.
4. Automated manuals (semi-automatics)
An automated manual is an ordinary manual gearbox and clutch, with motors doing the clutch and gear changes for you. It's cheap to build and saves fuel, but there's a noticeable pause and nod of the car between gears, and the clutch and actuators wear like any manual clutch. These are the gearboxes to be most careful about on an older car.
| Brand | Name | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Toyota | MMT / MultiMode, x-shift | Aygo, Yaris, Corolla, Auris (not to be confused with Multidrive S, which is a CVT) |
| Ford | Durashift EST | The 2002 to 2008 Fiesta |
| Vauxhall | Easytronic | Corsa, Meriva, Astra and others |
| Peugeot and Citroën | 2-Tronic, ETG, EGS | Various small models (later EAT6 and EAT8 are conventional automatics) |
| Fiat | Dualogic | 500, Panda, Punto |
Why the exact engine matters
The gearbox is tied to the model, engine and year, not just the name. The Ford Fiesta shows why: the 2002 to 2008 Fiesta "automatic" was usually the Durashift automated manual, the 2008 to 2012 Fiesta 1.4 automatic was a conventional four-speed, and many later Fiesta automatics used the PowerShift dual-clutch. Three very different gearboxes, all sold as an automatic Fiesta.
How to find out what a car has
- Ask the seller for the exact model, engine and gearbox name. A dealer should be able to tell you.
- Look it up by model, engine and year in a manufacturer brochure, owner's manual or a reputable review.
- Look at the gear lever: a conventional automatic usually has P, R, N and D. Many automated manuals have no P (park) position and you use the handbrake instead.
- Check recalls with the registration on the DVSA recall checker.
- Ask for the service history, especially gearbox fluid changes on a CVT or dual-clutch.
Test drive checks for any automatic
- Start it from cold and select Drive and Reverse: it should engage within a second or so, without a clunk.
- Pull away gently and firmly: no slipping (revs rising without the car speeding up), shuddering or jerking.
- Changes should be smooth, both accelerating and slowing down.
- No warning lights on the dashboard once the engine is running.
- No whining or grinding noises that change with speed.
Looking for an automatic?
Browse automatic cars for sale or post a wanted ad saying exactly what you want. Before you buy, read timing belt vs chain, how to read an MOT history and our used car checks.